| Rt Hon Charles Bowyer Adderley | 12 March 1858 | 11 June 1859 |
| Rt Hon Henry Austin Bruce | 26 April 1864 | 26 June 1866 |
| Rt Hon Henry Thomas Lowry Corry | 25 June 1866 | 19 March 1867 |
| Rt Hon Robert Montagu | 19 March 1867 | 1 December 1868 |
| Rt Hon George Francis Hamilton | 4 April 1878 | 21 April 1880 |
| Rt Hon Anthony John Mundella | 3 May 1880 | 9 June 1885 |
| Rt Hon Sir William Hart Dyke, bt | 25 January 1887 | 11 August 1892 |
| Rt Hon Rev Arthur Herbert Dyke Acland | 25 August 1892 | 21 June 1895 |