| John Scott | 1774 | 1774 |
| John Stewart | 26 June 1798 | 9 December 1799 |
| William Conyngham Plunket | 1803 | 1805 |
| John Doherty | 18 June 1827 | 23 December 1830 |
| Prof Philip Cecil Crampton | 1830 | 1834 |
| Michael O'Loghlen | 29 April 1835 | 31 August 1835 |
| Stephen Woulfe | 10 November 1836 | 3 February 1837 |
| Rt Hon David Richard Pigot | 11 February 1839 | 11 August 1840 |
| Rt Hon James Henry Monahan | 16 July 1846 | 21 December 1847 |
| Rt Hon James Whiteside | February 1852 | December 1852 |
| John David Fitzgerald | March 1855 | March 1856 |
| Dr Rickard Deasy | 1859 | February 1860 |
| John George | February 1859 | July 1859 |
| Thomas O'Hagan | 1860 | 1861 |
| Prof James Anthony Lawson | February 1861 | 1865 |
| Edward Sullivan | 1865 | June 1866 |
| Michael Morris | 3 August 1866 | 1 November 1866 |
| Richard Dowse | 14 February 1870 | 13 January 1872 |
| Dr Christopher Palles | 6 February 1872 | 5 November 1872 |
| Hugh Law | 18 November 1872 | 1873 |
| David Robert Plunket | 29 January 1875 | 1877 |
| William Moore Johnson | 24 May 1880 | 17 November 1881 |
| John Naish | 9 January 1883 | 19 December 1883 |
| John George Gibson | November 1885 | January 1886 |
| John George Gibson | August 1886 | 1887 |
| Dodgson Hamilton Madden | 1888 | 1890 |
| John Atkinson | 1889 | 1892 |
| Charles Hare Hemphill | 1892 | |
| Edward Henry Carson | June 1892 | August 1892 |
| William Kenny | August 1895 | 1898 |
| Dunbar Plunket Barton | January 1898 | January 1900 |
| Redmond John Barry | 20 December 1905 | 2 December 1909 |
| James Chambers | 19 March 1917 | September 1917 |
| Rt Hon Arthur Warren Samuels | 12 September 1917 | 7 April 1918 |
| Denis Stanislaus Henry | 27 November 1918 | 6 July 1919 |
| Daniel Martin Wilson | 1919 | 1921 |
| Thomas Watters Brown | June 1921 | August 1921 |